Categories
WHERE ARE THEY NOW?

What Happened To The Fine Bros?

The digital age has seen the rise of many internet celebrities, but few have experienced the meteoric rise and subsequent controversy like the Fine Bros.

Benny and Rafi Fine, collectively known as the Fine Bros, are creators behind the popular “React” series on YouTube. This deep dive will explore their journey, the controversies they faced, and the impact they had on the YouTube community.

The Rise of The Fine Bros

The Beginning (2007-2010)

Year Milestone
2007 The Fine Bros launched their YouTube channel.
2009 Introduced the “Kids React” series, which quickly gained popularity.
2010 Reached 100,000 subscribers.

The Fine Bros found a niche in capturing genuine reactions of people, starting with kids, to various viral videos, trends, and cultural phenomena.

Peak Popularity (2011-2015)

Year Subscribers Notable Achievements
2011 500,000 Launched “Teens React” and “Elders React”.
2012 1 million Won a Daytime Emmy for their “Kids React” series.
2014 10 million Introduced “YouTubers React”, bringing in other popular creators.
2015 14 million Expanded their brand with spin-offs and international versions.

The Controversy: React World (2016)

In 2016, the Fine Bros, pioneers of the “React” video format on YouTube, announced a new venture called “React World”.

The program was designed to allow creators from around the globe to license the Fine Bros’ format, enabling them to produce their own localized versions of “React” videos.

On the surface, this seemed like a promising expansion strategy. However, the announcement was met with significant backlash from the YouTube community for several reasons.

Perceived Greed: Monopolizing a Generic Video Format

The essence of the “React” format is simple: film individuals or groups as they watch and respond to various content.

This format, in the eyes of many, was seen as too generic to be owned or licensed. By attempting to license this format, the Fine Bros were perceived as trying to lay claim to a broad style of video that many creators had been using long before the Fine Bros popularized it.

The backlash was rooted in a fundamental belief: that the Fine Bros were not just licensing their specific style or branding, but were trying to control and profit from a widespread video format.

This move was seen by many as a greedy attempt to capitalize on something that should remain in the public domain.

Trademark Issues: The “React” Trademark Controversy

Further fuelling the controversy was the discovery that the Fine Bros had filed to trademark the word “React” in the context of online video series. This raised alarms in the creator community.

The fear was that, if granted, this trademark would give the Fine Bros the legal power to take down or claim revenue from any video that used a similar format but didn’t license it from them.

The potential implications were vast. Would creators be sued or have their videos taken down for simply using the word “React” in their titles or for having a similar format?

The uncertainty around these questions caused widespread concern.

Community Backlash: Betraying the Open Nature of YouTube

YouTube, since its inception, has been a platform that champions creativity, openness, and community. Many creators and fans felt that the Fine Bros’ move with React World was a betrayal of these principles. The idea of putting a price tag on a generic format seemed to go against the very ethos of what YouTube stood for.

Moreover, the Fine Bros had built their empire on the support of the YouTube community. Their subscribers, fellow creators, and fans had played a significant role in their success. The React World initiative was seen by many as a slap in the face to this community, especially to smaller creators who might not have the resources to license the format.

What Happened To The Fine Bros? 1

Impact of the Controversy

Metric Before React World After React World
Subscribers 14 million Lost over 1 million in a week
Video Views Average 2-3 million per video Dropped significantly, with many videos receiving less than 1 million views

Aftermath and Recovery

Following the backlash, the Fine Bros rescinded their trademark applications and cancelled the React World program. They issued a public apology, acknowledging their mistakes.

Rebuilding Trust (2017-2019)

Year Subscribers Notable Actions
2017 15 million Focused on producing quality content and engaging with their community.
2018 16 million Collaborated with other creators to rebuild bridges.
2019 17 million Introduced new series and formats to diversify their content.

Legacy and Impact

Despite the controversy, the Fine Bros have left an indelible mark on YouTube:

  • Pioneering Format: Their “React” format has been emulated by many, showcasing the power of genuine human reactions.
  • Community Engagement: They have collaborated with countless YouTubers, bridging communities and fostering collaboration.
  • Business Model: Their attempt with React World, though flawed, showcased the potential of franchising in the digital age.

Conclusion

The Fine Bros’ journey is a testament to the dynamic nature of the internet. Their rise, fall, and recovery offer valuable lessons in understanding the power of community, the pitfalls of ambition, and the importance of adaptability in the digital age.

Categories
WHERE ARE THEY NOW?

What Happened To Miranda Sings aka Colleen Ballinger?

Colleen Ballinger, known for her outrageous and larger-than-life character, Miranda Sings, started her journey on YouTube back in 2008.

This satirical character was created as a mockery of the numerous self-absorbed and seemingly talentless individuals aspiring to be famous on social media.

Miranda’s outrageous persona, characterized by her iconic red lipstick, unusual wardrobe choices, and off-key singing, quickly captivated YouTube viewers. By 2009, her channel started gaining attention.

However, it was in 2010 that Ballinger decided to take Miranda Sings on a live comedy tour across North America and Europe, selling out venues and truly expanding her reach.

Year Subscriber Count Total Views
2009 100,000 10 million
2010 500,000 50 million
2015 5 million 1 billion
2021 10 million 2 billion

A Netflix Original: Haters Back Off!

Miranda Sings’ fame grew to such a point that Netflix took notice. In 2016, “Haters Back Off!“, an original series delving into the fictional life of Miranda Sings, premiered.

This marked a significant milestone, not only for Ballinger but also for YouTubers as a whole. It was among the first times a major streaming service had adapted a YouTube character into a series.

However, the show only lasted two seasons before its cancellation in 2017. While some fans praised it for its quirky humor and unique perspective, critics found it less appealing, stating that the character’s charm didn’t fully translate to a scripted show format.

Controversies and Criticisms

While Miranda’s career trajectory had been mostly upwards, it hasn’t been devoid of controversy. In 2019, Ballinger was criticized for sending lingerie to a 13-year-old fan. She quickly apologized, stating it was part of a gag gift and that she didn’t mean to make the fan or his family uncomfortable.

In 2020, Ballinger faced allegations of racism and mockery of mental illness through her character, Miranda. Critics pointed out certain videos where the character appeared to imitate stereotypes and behave in ways that were derogatory towards individuals with mental illnesses.

Each time, Ballinger addressed these controversies head-on, apologizing and promising to be more mindful. However, these instances marked significant challenges in her career and led to a dip in viewership and subscriber growth.

What Happened To Miranda Sings aka Colleen Ballinger? 1

The Decline of Miranda Sings

After the controversies, Ballinger saw a decrease in viewership and subscriber growth, as reflected in the table below:

Year Subscriber Count Total Views
2019 10.5 million 2.1 billion
2020 10.3 million 2.15 billion
2021 10 million 2 billion

Despite these challenges, Ballinger continues to evolve the character and remains a key player in the world of YouTube comedy. But the question remains: will Miranda Sings be able to reclaim her previous heights of popularity?

The Legacy of Miranda Sings

Despite the controversies and the ongoing challenges, it’s undeniable that Miranda Sings left a significant mark on YouTube culture. The channel was a pioneer in transforming YouTube personas into full-fledged careers, setting a precedent for content creators everywhere.

Whether she’s at the peak of her popularity or facing challenges, Miranda Sings remains an important chapter in the book of YouTube’s history. Her rise and fall illustrate the potential and perils of digital stardom in the age of social media.

Check out more Rise and Fall deep dives into Alex Day, Onision, CharlieIsSoCoolLike, Toby Turner, Eugenia Cooney and more.

Q1: Who is Miranda Sings?

A: Miranda Sings is a fictional character created and portrayed by American comedian Colleen Ballinger. This character is a satire of self-absorbed, talentless, and fame-hungry individuals often found on social media.

Q2: Who is Colleen Ballinger?

A: Colleen Ballinger is an American comedian, actress, singer, and YouTube personality, known for her character, Miranda Sings. She has expanded her career to include live performances, a Netflix original series, and appearances on various talk shows.

Q3: When was the Miranda Sings YouTube channel created?

A: The Miranda Sings YouTube channel was created in 2008.

Q4: What is Miranda Sings’ distinctive look?

A: Miranda Sings is characterized by her off-key singing, peculiar dance moves, childish demeanor, and exaggerated red lipstick smeared well beyond her lips. She often wears mismatched outfits that add to her comedic appeal.

Q5: What kind of content does Miranda Sings create?

A: The content on the Miranda Sings channel is a mix of satirical tutorials, performances, vlogs, and comedic skits. The character’s off-key singing, over-the-top dance moves, and misguided advice create a sense of cringe comedy.

Q6: How did Colleen Ballinger leverage her YouTube success?

A: Beyond YouTube, Ballinger took Miranda Sings on a live comedy tour and starred in the Netflix original series “Haters Back Off!” She also makes appearances on various talk shows and collaborates with other YouTube personalities and celebrities.

Q7: What is “Haters Back Off!” about?

A: “Haters Back Off!” is a Netflix original series that delves into the fictional life of Miranda Sings. The series focuses on Miranda’s family life and her quest for fame. It ran for two seasons from 2016 to 2017.

Q8: What controversies has Miranda Sings faced?

A: Miranda Sings has faced several controversies, including criticism for sending inappropriate gifts to a minor fan, and accusations of perpetuating stereotypes and making light of mental illnesses through her comedic character.

Q9: How has Miranda Sings influenced YouTube culture?

A: Miranda Sings was one of the first YouTube characters to be developed into a full-blown career, setting a precedent for content creators. Her comedic style has had a significant influence on YouTube culture, particularly in the realm of cringe comedy.

Q10: How has Colleen Ballinger dealt with the decline in Miranda Sings’ popularity?

A: Despite a decrease in viewership and subscriber growth following several controversies, Ballinger continues to evolve the character of Miranda Sings, maintaining relevance in the ever-changing landscape of YouTube comedy. She addresses criticisms head-on and promises to be more considerate in her content creation.

Categories
WHERE ARE THEY NOW?

What Happened To Shane Dawson?

Shane Dawson, born Shane Lee Yaw, is a YouTuber who came to prominence in the mid-to-late 2000s and is known for his controversial content and eccentric personality.

His career has seen significant ups and downs, with a series of controversies that have led to a notable decline in his popularity.

Here’s a deep dive into his rise and fall.

If you like this then why note check out other “rise and fall” style blogs on Smosh, Alex Day, Tyler Oakley and more

The Rise

Shane Dawson started his career on YouTube in 2008, quickly gaining a massive following due to his comedy sketches, parodies, and vlogs. His early content often featured him impersonating celebrities, such as Paris Hilton and Miley Cyrus, which attracted a huge young audience. His channels saw exponential growth, as seen in the table below:

Year Subscribers
2008 100,000
2010 2 million
2013 6 million
2015 8 million
2017 11 million

Dawson later transitioned to creating more mature content, such as documentaries and investigative videos on controversial internet figures. His series on Jeffree Star, Jake Paul, and Tana Mongeau became incredibly popular, boosting his subscribers to over 20 million by 2019.

Podcast Career

In addition to his YouTube success, Dawson also hosted a podcast, “Shane and Friends,” from 2013 to 2017. The podcast had a successful run with over 140 episodes, featuring interviews with celebrities, YouTubers, and social media influencers. It added another layer to Dawson’s online presence and diversified his content, further contributing to his growth.

The Fall

Dawson’s fall from grace began in 2020, when several controversies surrounding his past content resurfaced. A few key incidents include:

  1. Old Racist Videos: Dawson faced backlash over old videos where he was seen using racial slurs and stereotypes. His impersonations, which had been a significant part of his initial success, were now seen as offensive and harmful.
  2. Inappropriate Comments and Actions Toward Minors: Dawson was accused of making sexualized comments and inappropriate actions towards underage fans in his past content.
  3. Association with Controversial Figures: Dawson’s close association with Jeffree Star, a beauty influencer with his own share of controversies, also hurt his image.

These controversies led to a significant decline in his popularity and subscriber count, as shown in the table below:

Year Subscribers
2019 23 million
2020 21 million
2021 20 million
2022 19 million

In June 2020, Dawson posted a video titled “Taking Accountability,” in which he apologized for his past behaviour. However, the apology was not well-received, with many criticizing him for not adequately addressing the issues.

Time Away from YouTube

Following the backlash, Dawson took a hiatus from YouTube. He was largely absent from the platform for about a year, with only occasional appearances on his fianc√© Ryland Adams’s channel. His hiatus marked a significant shift in his career, as he had been a constant presence on YouTube for over a decade.

What Happened To Shane Dawson? 1

The Aftermath

Dawson attempted a comeback in 2021 with a video titled “The Haunting of Shane Dawson,” but the response was mixed. While some fans were glad to see him return, many others felt that he hadn’t adequately addressed his past controversies.

In 2023, Dawson remains a polarizing figure. His influence and subscriber count have significantly declined from his peak, and his reputation has been severely damaged by his past controversies.

As of 2023, his subscriber count stands as follows:

Year Subscribers
2023 18 million

This steep fall from his peak of 23 million subscribers in 2019 underscores the impact of his controversies on his popularity.

However, it’s worth noting that despite the backlash, Dawson retains a core group of fans who continue to support him. His videos, though far less frequent than before, still generate millions of views, indicating that he still holds a place in the online space, albeit a diminished one.

Current Endeavors

Since his return to YouTube, Dawson has tried to steer his content in a different direction, focusing more on personal growth and less controversial topics. However, he hasn’t been able to fully escape the shadow of his past controversies. His attempts to move forward are often met with mixed reactions, with some viewers appreciating his efforts to change, while others remain sceptical of his sincerity.

In addition to his YouTube content, Dawson has also tried to diversify his online presence. He’s made several appearances on his fianc√©’s podcast, “The Sip,” and has hinted at working on a new series, though details remain vague.

Conclusion

Shane Dawson’s rise and fall serve as a stark reminder of the power and perils of internet fame. His career has been marked by incredible highs and significant lows, and his story continues to evolve. His controversies have opened up important conversations about accountability and the lasting impact of harmful content.

While it remains to be seen whether Dawson will ever regain his former status, his story offers valuable lessons for content creators and audiences alike about the importance of respectful and responsible content.

If you like this, check out the Where Are They Now Playlist